Myrtle Beach, S.C.

New York Prime

 5.0 Avg. rating based on 3 reviews

405 28th Ave N, Myrtle Beach, South Carolina 29577   
(843) 448-8081

About New York Prime

If you’re looking for a choice, top-notch steakhouse that only serves the finest cuisine, look no further than New York Prime. Boasting top cuts of USDA grade prime that are aged for more than four weeks, New York Prime provides the best quality food for hungry patrons. Even the potatoes, shrimp, and other ingredients at New York Prime are the best you can get, which means that the menu is a little expensive, but don’t let that stop you from trying out the delectable food here.

New York Prime Food

Only open for dinner, the menu at New York Prime features an array of delicious options. Begin your meal with an appetizer like oysters on a half shell, shrimp, oysters Rockefeller, baked shrimp, shellfish bisque, jumbo lump crab meat, carpaccio, thick cut sizzling bacon, or a seafood platter. If you’re in the mood for lighter fare, New York Prime offers a few salad options. Choose from the beefsteak tomato and onion salad, hearts of lettuce with slice tomato salad, caesar salad, or New York Prime’s chopped Italian salad. Of course, the star of the show at New York Prime is the steak menu. Steak lovers have a choice between several different cuts of steak such as the following: Delmonico steak, petite New York strip, New York strip, center cut filet of rib eye, bone-in rib steak, center cut filet, petite filet, porterhouse for two, or a chopped steak of prime, aged beef. There are also seafood options like live lobster and sea bass. All of the sides at New York Prime are ala carte and are available in individual and table sizes. Along with your steak, you can enjoy sides like giant baked potatoes, cheese mashed potatoes, lyonnaise, onion rings, fries, hash browns, sauteed onions, sauteed mushrooms, creamed spinach, or asparagus with hollandaise sauce. Cap off your meal with a tasty dessert. The dessert menu features cheesecake, giant chocolate chip cookie, cinnamon walnut apple pie, white chocolate banana cream pie, and a giant chocolate cake.

New York Prime Atmosphere

New York Prime is a small yet cozy restaurant that offers high-end service and food. Much thought was put into this restaurant, including exact dimensions for table and seat heights, as well as fine-tuned acoustics to make a perfectly balanced not-too-loud yet not-too-quiet surrounding. This is not the place to go if you’re expecting a casual atmosphere; New York Prime prides themselves on their 5-star service including the use of crumb rakes to clean tables. Many visitors also say that the setting of New York Prime is reminiscent of “old-school” New York, hence the name of the restaurant.    

User Reviews
New York Prime Reviews

See what 3 users said about New York Prime:


Avg. rating based on 3 reviews

  • Dr Don Sabino

    The best of the best!! Big dollars but go to Peter Lugers and get treated like shit.

    Don Sabino user

  • Dr Don Sabino

    The best of the best!! Big dollars but go to Peter Lugers and get treated like shit.

    Don Sabino user

  • New York Prime Myrtle Beach

    Best lobsters and steaks anywhere! The apple walnut cinnamon pie is to die for!

    Michael Bailey user